Welcome, visitor! [ Register | Login


Justice in the dock: The innocent are convicted, the guilty go free

  • Street: Hans-Grade-Allee 17
  • City: Behlendorf
  • State: New Hampshire
  • Country: Germany
  • Zip/Postal Code: 23919
  • Listed: 17 Mayıs 2018 22:17
  • Expires: 79 days, 9 hours




(Macmillan £16.99)

There is power to anonymity. If you conceal your identity, for whatever reason, there’s simply so much more you can say. You may not get the acclaim or the kudos for saying it, but your freedom to say it is absolute.

The Secret Barrister is the pseudonym of a jobbing barrister — possibly male, possibly female — who really doesn’t like what has been done to the justice system, and what is still being done to it.

This book, like one or two nowadays, started as a blog but, unlike most blogs, this one was read by a lot of people and won awards. For whoever he or she is, The Secret Barrister can write. Among bloggers, this is unusual, to say the least. Among writers generally, it’s less common than you might imagine. Among barristers, it’s close to miraculous.

An anonymous barrister reveals the injustice in the UK legal system in a new book adapted from an award-winning blog (file image)

The very phrase ‘Secret Barrister’ suggests something a bit larky and satirical, full of jokes about wigs. But this is a serious, if not solemn, book, in which SB (as I think we’ll call him/her) patiently explains the justice system we have, and then delineates precisely how it has gone wrong. It’s a damning piece of work. Everyone who has any interest in public life should read it.

SB’s first point is that we, the sort of people who might read this book, take it all for granted. ‘I imagine few of us devote much, if any, time to thinking critically about our criminal justice system; to considering how and why we have this particular way of doing justice, or reflecting on the impact it has upon the thousands of people — defendants, witnesses and victims — who pass through the system every year.’

Compare it with the way we all talk endlessly about the NHS, or about schools. ‘And this I find odd; because criminal justice affects us all.’



Why the Queen’s voice is much DEEPER now: Fascinating study… Did the weapons expert really kill himself? Or did he have a…
Share this article
Share Does it, though? Most of us, in our cosy middle-class bubbles, assume we’re not very likely to get much closer to the Crown Court than watching repeats of Kavanagh QC.

‘The law, as it stands, is the province only of the very rich, who can afford the vast sums it now costs to hire a lawyer, and the very poor, who can call upon legal aid. We in the middle assume we are safe from this process, so we think no more about it. We’re even quite good at getting out of jury service: a regular dinner-party boast.

But amid this complacency, the system is in crisis. The Crown Prosecution Service is a mess. Over the past eight years it has lost more than a third of its workforce. One-quarter of prosecutors have been sacrificed through voluntary redundancy schemes in an aim to meet expenditure cuts of 27 per cent imposed since 2009-10.

How much training are magistrates given?
18 Total number of hours a magistrate spends training


‘I’ve seen some of the best people leave, seizing their golden ticket to another civil service post where there’s a fighting chance of managing their caseload, without the stress of trying to achieve – https://twitter.com/search?q=achieve&src=typd the impossible dream of running a national prosecuting agency for less than it costs to give free television licences to pensioners.’

SB doesn’t name names. But he/she does say the Justice Ministry is considered low priority by the Government, a soft target for cuts.

The upshot is that two things are happening regularly that shouldn’t: innocent people are being convicted, and the guilty ones are going free.

SB is damning about magistrates’ courts. Magistrates are untrained volunteers, equipped only with goodwill, and sometimes not even that. And yet 94 per cent of all criminal cases are decided at magistrate level.

What other country in the world outsources so much of its judicial decision-making to people without training, but who often belong to the right golf club? None. It’s only us.

THE SECRET BARRISTER (Macmillan £16.99)

The Government is mainly concerned, it seems, with throughput in the courts, with ‘getting the numbers through the door and out again, as inexpensively and swiftly as possible’. SB calls this ‘roulette framed as justice’.

In 2015, an inspection found that nearly one in five charging decisions made by police was wrong, and nearly one in ten made by the CPS was wrong too. That could be you who’s charged wrongly. Worse, it could be me. Because that’s when the Innocence Tax comes in.

Suppose you are wrongly charged with something. You go through the courts, you are refused legal aid, you spend £100,000 on a lawyer, you are found not guilty. You then try to claim back from the Government all the money you spent on legal fees. But you can’t. Because in 2012 the rules were changed. SB tal


12 total views, 1 today


Listing ID: 8185afdd533e2cc1

Report problem

Processing your request, Please wait....